Showing posts with label Andrew Torrance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Andrew Torrance. Show all posts

Thursday, March 6, 2014

Design Patents In the Modern World - Academic Day Compedium

Last April, Stanford Law School hosted a symposium on the subject of Design Patents in the Modern World.  We followed the symposium closely last year because it was the largest gathering of design patent practitioners, scholars, and owners ever in one place, as far as we can tell.  The Design Patents in the Modern World conference, and other like it last year, signals that design patents have truly arrived as an important, and well-respected form of intellectual property that is finally being used in the manner it was always intended.

Last night, the Stanford Technology Law Review published a compendium of articles discussed and presented during the academic day at last year's conference as Volume 17, Issue 1 of the publication. From the editors - "[t]he Articles in this issue are leading scholarship on design patents, on topics ranging from the doctrine’s theoretical underpinnings, to the scope of design patent protection, to the proper remedy for infringement."

Each of the design patent articles published by the Stanford Technology Law Review last night is a must-read for any design patent enthusiast.  Here is the complete compendium (350 pages), or you can link to each of the articles individually, below.  Enjoy!

Progress and Competition in Design
Mark P. McKenna & Katherine J. Strandburg

Functionality and Graphical User Interface Design Patents
Michael Risch

Virtual Designs
Jason J. Du Mont & Mark D. Janis

(R)evolution in Design Patentable Subject Matter: The Shifting Meaning of “Article of Manufacture”
William J. Seymour & Andrew W. Torrance

A Rational System of Design Patent Remedies
Mark A. Lemley

Overlapping Intellectual Property Doctrines: Election of Rights Versus Selection of Remedies
Laura A. Heymann

Design Patents: Law Without Design
Peter Lee & Madhavi Sunder

Moving Beyond the Standard Criticisms of Design Patents
Sarah Burstein

Monday, January 27, 2014

Design Patent Links - Jan. 27, 2014

Most of the exciting news in the design patent space in the last few weeks has been coming from the Federal Circuit.  But there have beet some smaller items in the news lateley,

Tracy-Gene Durkin and David K.S. Cornwell authored a summary of the Patent Trial and Appeal Board's decision to deny inter partes review in ATAS Int'l, Inc. v. Centria.  This decision is the first IPR decision regarding a design patent, and the denial seems to suggest that design patent defendants should seek to assert only a few solid references when seeking IPR.

PC World authored an article last Thursday about the preliminary injunction that Blackberry is seeking against Typo in the Northern District of California.  It will be interesting to see how the court handles the issue of contributory design patent infringement, which is not a common issue in design patent cases.

Kenyon and Kenyon issued a design patent notice about a finding of non-infringement in Cohen Harel v. KK Int’l Trading Co. in the Eastern District of New York.  The case involved refillable lighters and the court found on summary judgment that no reasonable trier of fact could find the designs of the two lighters substantially similar.

Finally, for those who may have missed it, Professors Andrew Torrance and Mark Janis participated in an "Evil Twin" debate regarding the scope, purpose, and value of design patents back in November at the University of Richmond School of Law.  The debate was unofficially titled  "Design Patents - Great Idea or Greatest Idea?"

Finally, it's not every day that a local design patent case makes the 5:00 news, but the latest design patent case by Alex & Ani against North Attleboro's Northeast Jewelers sounds like it is gearing up to be an interesting case!

Tuesday, November 19, 2013

Design Patent Links - Nov. 19, 2013



We start this week’s design patent links with a story from the lighter side of design patent litigation… and shapewear… Jenny B. Davis of the ABA Journal has penned an epic poem about the Spanx v. Yummie Tummie design patent fight. It’s a funny read for anyone interested in design patents, shapewear, or reality TV. For everyone else, it will just be strange and confusing…

Amaya Singh of the Indian IP firm, Lex Orbis, has authored an interesting article on the differences between U.S. design patent law and that of India. One interesting fact about Indian design patent law is that designs are still judged for aesthetic value. Ms. Singh explains that Indian design patents must be “‘Judged solely by the eye’ [which] has been interpreted to mean that every design is to be looked at for an ‘eye appeal’, i.e. the aesthetic value of the design needs to be gauged.”

China IPR is reporting that the Chinese Patent Office is considering draft regulations that would allow for design patent protection for graphical user interfaces. Currently, the Chinese Patent Office does not allow such design patents.

Here in the United States, design patents for graphical user interfaces continues to be a source of debate. This week, PatentlyO published a guest post by Michael Risch, Professor of Law at Villanova University School of Law regarding “Functionality and Graphical User Interface Design Patents.” The post is a preview of Professor Risch’s article in the Stanford Technology Law Review, in which he takes the position that functional elements of GUI’s should be excluded from design patent protection.

Last week, Richmond School of law hosted their seventh Annual Evil Twin Debate in the law school's moot court room. This year’s debate featured Professor Mark Janis of Indiana University's Maurer School of Law and Professor Andrew Torrance of the University of Kansas School of Law. They debated the topic Design Patents: Great Idea, or Greatest Idea? The law school has posted video of the debate in years past, and we will add a link to the debate as soon as it becomes available.

The California Patent Litigation blog discusses Intellectual Property Owner’s Association 2013 IP Record, and its potential implications for design patent litigation. Apparently, there were 658 more design patent applications filed in 2012 than in 2011 and that number is likely to grow again in 2013.

Check back next week for more design patent links! And don’t forget to sign up for Suffolk Law School’s design patent conference this Friday! See you there.

Monday, April 1, 2013

Design Patent Links


Aside from the Federal Circuit’s decision in In re Owens, which we covered last week, it was a fairly quiet week in design patent law. However, this week promises to bring plenty of design patent news from Stanford’s Design Patents in the Modern World conference, which takes place on Friday and Saturday of this week. Here are the design patent links from the past week! 

According to the law firm of Smith & Hopen, USPTO hiring for design patent examiners has remained flat since 2008, whereas the number of examiners for utility patents has increased by 32% over that same period. This despite the fact that design applications rose by 14%. 

ComputerWorld noted the 13 design patents for the Microsoft surface that were recently issued by the PTO. Microsoft’s new design patents cover several aspects of the Surface, including its signature keyboard/covers.

Sarah Burstein, Associate Professor of Law at the University of Oklahoma, provided her analysis of In re Owens in a guest post on Patently-O.

Professor Burstein will be among several design patent scholars presenting at Stanford’s design patent conference, “Design Patents in the Modern World.” The conference is scheduled to take place this Friday and Saturday 4/5-4/6. Professor Andrew Torrance of the University of Kansas School of Law will also be presenting a paper co-authored by myself entitled “(R)evolution in Design Patent Subject Matter: The Shifting Meaning of ‘Article of Manufacture.’” The conference is open to the public. Any design patent enthusiasts planning to attend should register here.

Monday, March 25, 2013

Design Patent Links


The last few weeks have seen a flurry of design patent activity, ranging from academia, Computer-Generated Icons, and even the fashion industry.  It’s far too much to post about separately, so, without further ado, we give you this week’s Design Patent Links!

“The Fashion Law” blog is reporting on Stella McCartney’s design patent for a bestselling Lucia mesh polka dot dress from her Fall 2012 collection.  The London based company’s design patent arrived just in time for fashion week.  According to New York Law School’s “Legal As She is Spoke” blog suggested that McCartney’s design patent was just for publicity, “but could prove not to be all that helpful.”

Real Housewifes of New York star and owner/inventor of Yummie Tummie Heather, Thomson, might beg to differ with Legal As She Spoke. Yummie Tummie was sued by shapewear heavy hitter Spanx on March 5, seeking a declaratory judgment of noninfringement of several of Ms. Thomson’s design patents after Yummie sent Spanx cease and desist letters concerning Spanx’s design patents.  The National Law Review provided a nice summary of this shapewear design patent case. Many other outfits are also covering the story, including IPWatchdog, Womens Wear Daily, New York Magazine, and the Huffington Post.  But what several commentators failed to mention is that this is not Yummie Tummie’s first design patent rodeo.  As we have mentioned before on this blog, Yummie Tummie settled a declaratory judgment action brought by Maidenform after Maidenform paid Yummie Tummie 6.75 Million.  In 2011, Yummie Tummie also filed a design patent infringement action against LF USA, a subsidiary of the Hong Kong-based apparel manufacturer Li & Fung, Ltd.  Yummie Tummie has aggressively defended its design patents in the past, and we suspect this case will be no different.  Spanx may be surprised by how not “Yummie” this case might become for them.

As design patents continue to gain credibility with practitioners, academia is also beginning to take note. On April 5-6, 2013, Stanford Law School will host “a major conference on design patents,” titled “Design Patents in the Modern World.” The conference is sponsored by the Stanford Program in Law, Science, & Technology, Samsung Electronics, Nike, and Google and will include public conference on April 5 and a one-day academic symposium with papers on design patents from the leading scholars in the world on design patent issues. Included among the articles slated for discussion is an article co-authored by yours truly and University of Kansas School of Law professor Andrew Torrance. The article is titled “(R)evolution in Design Patent Subject Matter: The Shifting Meaning of ‘Article of Manufacture,” and provides an historical review of the “article of manufacture” requirement in design patent law. Stanford’s design patent conference will be open to the public.