Wednesday, May 7, 2014

Supreme Court's Octane Fitness Decision Impacts Design Patent Litigation

Yesterday, two of the editors of The Ordinary Observer published a summary of the Supreme Court's recent decision in Octane Fitness, LLC v. ICON Health & Fitness, Inc.  Dkt. No. 12-1184 (Apr. 29, 2014) (link goes to the opinion).   

Octane Fitness is one of the most significant patent rulings to come down from the Supreme Court in recent years, and for that reason alone it deserves mention here.  The decision substantially increases the possibility that a prevailing party in patent litigation will obtain his or her attorneys' fees when the court finds that the case is "exceptional" under Section 285 of the Patent Act.  The increased likelihood of obtaining fees should affect the considerations of patent owners seeking to assert weak patents in litigation, and may embolden patent defendants to defend more cases as opposed to settling out early at an affordable price.  For more information, follow the link below to the IP Law Advisory published by Lando & Anastasi, LLP.

W. Seymour, Esq. & E. Carnevale, Esq., The Supreme Court Makes it Easier to Obtain Attorneys' Fees in Patent Cases.

Octane Fitness is relevant in the design patent world for two additional reasons:
  1. Because stakes in design patent cases tend to be lower than in utility patent cases, the new considerations for plaintiffs and defendants discussed above apply with that much more force in the design patent context; and 
  2. Octane Fitness overruled the Federal Circuit's test articulated in Brooks Furniture Manufacturing, Inc. v. Dutalier International, Inc., 393 F.3d 1378 (Fed. Cir. 2005) - a design patent case.
We will be on the lookout over the coming months to see whether Octane Fitness has a substantial impact on design patent litigation, or on the caliber of design patent suits being brought.

Friday, May 2, 2014

Design Patent Roundup - May 2, 2014

It has been a few weeks since our last design patent roundup, but you will be seeing a lot more of us through the summer. This week brings us only two new design patent cases, including another design patent enforcement action brought by Oakley in California and a design patent case about mobile phone charging stations in Texas. See the designs and accused products after the jump!


Wednesday, April 30, 2014

Inter Partes Review Invalidates First Design Patent

On Monday, April 21, the Patent Trial and Appeal Board handed down a milestone final decision, for the first time invalidating a design patent challenged in inter partes Review.  Munchkin, Inc. v. Luv N' Care, Ltd., No. IPR2013-00072 (P.T.A.B. Apr. 21, 2014) (Paper No. 28).


Thursday, April 3, 2014

Federal Circuit Alert: MRC Innovations, Inc. v. Hunter Mfg., LLP

Yesterday, the Federal Circuit affirmed the decision of the Northern District of Ohio to invalidate two design patents held by MRC Innovations (“MRC”) for athletic team shirts for dogs. See MRC Innovations, Inc. v. Hunter Mfg., LLP, --- F.3d ----, No. 2013-1433, 2014 WL 1303368 (Fed. Cir. April 2, 2014). The case was successfully argued by design patent guru Perry Saidman of the Saidman DesignLaw Group and is a noteworthy follow-up the Federal Circuit’s decision in High Point.



The design-patents-in-suit were U.S. Design Patent Nos. 634,488 S (“’488 Patent”) and D634,487 S (“’487 Patent”), both directed to an athletic team jersey for a dog. Through the course of discovery, it became clear that MRC had previously sold two earlier versions of its jersey designs – “the V2 Jersey” and “the Eagles Jersey” more than 1 year prior to the relevant date of the ’487 and ’488 Patents. Below are images of the prior art jerseys:


Based on the prior sale of these jerseys, the district court held that both of MRC’s patents were invalid as obvious, using the Eagles jersey as the primary reference against the ’488 Patent. On appeal, MRC argued that the district court’s decision violated the Federal Circuit’s recent decision in High Point Design LLC v. Buyers Direct, Inc., 730 F.3d 1301, 1314 (Fed.Cir.2013) because the Eagles jersey was not “basically the same” as the design of the ’488 Patent and because, according to MRC, the district court failed to give a verbal description of the similarities between the Eagles jersey and the ’488 design. MRC pointed to three perceived differences between the ’488 design and the prior art:

(1) the patented design has a V-neck collar where the Eagles jersey has a round neck; (2) the patented design contains an interlock fabric panel on the side portion of the design rather than mesh; and (3) the patented design contains additional ornamental surge stitching on the rear portion of the jersey.
MRC argued that the district court overlooked these differences and focused on the claimed design at “too high a level of abstraction. 

First, the Federal Circuit explained that the district court’s verbal description of the ’488 design patent was sufficient, reasoning that “High Point makes clear that the purpose of requiring district courts to describe the claimed design in words is so that the parties and appellate courts can discern the trial court's reasoning in identifying a primary reference. . . . It is entirely clear from the district court's opinion what it considered to be the relevant design characteristics of the ’488 patented design.” (emphasis added). Applying this standard, the court found that the district court’s explanation as to why the Eagles jersey was “basically the same” was adequate:

the district court pointed out three key similarities between the claimed design and the Eagles jersey: an opening at the collar portion for the head, two openings and sleeves stitched to the body of the jersey for limbs, and a body portion on which a football logo is applied. . . . If the district court's analysis had ended there, it might indeed have failed to meet the High Point verbal description requirement.  However, the district court went on to point out two additional similarities between the two designs: first, the Eagles jersey is made “primarily of a mesh and interlock fabric”; and second, it contains at least some ornamental surge stitching—both features found in the ’488 claimed design.
Next, the Federal Circuit affirmed the district court’s holding that the Eagles jersey was “basically the same,” and held that a primary reference need not be identical in order to be “basically the same.” “That there are slight differences in the precise placement of the interlock fabric and the ornamental stitching does not defeat a claim of obviousness; if the designs were identical, no obviousness analysis would be required.” (emphasis added). Based on the basic similarity of the ’488 design and the Eagles Jersey, the court affirmed the underlying finding of obviousness.

The court’s analysis with respect to the ’487 Patent was based on the same reasoning, while using the below “Sporty K9” baseball jersey as the primary reference. 


MRC does not appear to change the Federal Circuit’s analysis in High Point. Rather, the court’s analysis suggests that the verbal description requirement in High Point was intended to be understood within the context of an obviousness analysis and was not intended to conflict with the Federal Circuit’s suggestion in Egyptian Goddess that detailed verbal descriptions of design patents are generally to be avoided. MRC is best viewed as applying a common sense framework to the verbal description requirement announced in High Point – all that is required is a verbal description of the patent sufficient to assess the correctness of the district court’s analysis – a detailed verbal description is not required.

Thursday, March 6, 2014

Design Patents In the Modern World - Academic Day Compedium

Last April, Stanford Law School hosted a symposium on the subject of Design Patents in the Modern World.  We followed the symposium closely last year because it was the largest gathering of design patent practitioners, scholars, and owners ever in one place, as far as we can tell.  The Design Patents in the Modern World conference, and other like it last year, signals that design patents have truly arrived as an important, and well-respected form of intellectual property that is finally being used in the manner it was always intended.

Last night, the Stanford Technology Law Review published a compendium of articles discussed and presented during the academic day at last year's conference as Volume 17, Issue 1 of the publication. From the editors - "[t]he Articles in this issue are leading scholarship on design patents, on topics ranging from the doctrine’s theoretical underpinnings, to the scope of design patent protection, to the proper remedy for infringement."

Each of the design patent articles published by the Stanford Technology Law Review last night is a must-read for any design patent enthusiast.  Here is the complete compendium (350 pages), or you can link to each of the articles individually, below.  Enjoy!

Progress and Competition in Design
Mark P. McKenna & Katherine J. Strandburg

Functionality and Graphical User Interface Design Patents
Michael Risch

Virtual Designs
Jason J. Du Mont & Mark D. Janis

(R)evolution in Design Patentable Subject Matter: The Shifting Meaning of “Article of Manufacture”
William J. Seymour & Andrew W. Torrance

A Rational System of Design Patent Remedies
Mark A. Lemley

Overlapping Intellectual Property Doctrines: Election of Rights Versus Selection of Remedies
Laura A. Heymann

Design Patents: Law Without Design
Peter Lee & Madhavi Sunder

Moving Beyond the Standard Criticisms of Design Patents
Sarah Burstein

Friday, February 21, 2014

Design Patent Roundup - Feb. 21, 2014


It has been an active week for asserting design patent claims.

Turbo Style Products, LLC v. Amazon.com, Inc., No. 2-14-cv-00125 (D. Utah Feb. 20, 2014)

If you blinked, then perhaps you missed Turbo Style Products’ Complaint asserting that Amazon.com is infringing two design patents it holds for car headlight “eyelash” accessories, as pictured below. Turbo Style filed a lawsuit accusing Amazon.com of infringing two U.S. design patents, D672917 and D675776, each titled “Headlight Accessory.” In particular, the Complaint asserts both direct infringement under 35 U.S.C. § 271(a) and contributory infringement under § 271(c), but notably not induced infringement under § 271(b). The Complaint also included causes of action for trade dress infringement and unfair competition under the Lanham Act and common law. Turbo Style is represented by Andrew Stavros and Austin Egan of Stavros Law. The case has been assigned to Magistrate Judge Dustin Pead.





The Gillette Company v. SD Blades et al, No. 1-14-cv-00153 (S.D. Ohio Feb. 18, 2014)

Turning from eyelashes to whiskers, Gillette asserted 6 different design patents related to razor blade cartridges and containers in a complaint against SD Blades. The patents at suit are D422751, D430023, D440874, D531518, D533684, and D604904. They relate to the design for such popular razors and razor blade cartridges, such as the Mach® and Venus® lines. A figure of a razor cartridge from the ‘684 patent is shown below. Gillette asserts direct infringement under § 271(a) and induced infringement under § 271(b). While Gillette, unlike Turbo Style, has not included Amazon.com as a party, the complaint centers on Gillette’s assertion that, “the SD Blades ‘Storefront’ on Amazon.com is part of an offering that allows third-party sellers to use Amazon.com’s website infrastructure to offer products for sale over the Internet…through which consumers purchase razor cartridges, dispensers for razor cartridges, and containers that infringe upon Gillette’s intellectual property and design patent rights.” Gillette is represented by Karen Kreider Gaunt and Tammy Imhoff of Dinsmore and Shohl. The case has been assigned to District Judge Michael R. Barrett.





Ames True Temper, Inc. v. Suncast Corp., 1-14-cv-00284 (M.D. Penn Feb. 18, 2014)

Perhaps the winter weather has caused tempers to flare. Ames True Temper is asserting its design patent D557101, titled, “D-Grip for Tool,” against Suncast. Accusing Suncast’s “Centerforce” snow shovel of infringing the design rights. Below is a side-by-side comparison of a figure from the ‘101 patent and the allegedly infringing snow shovel model. Ames True Temper is represented by David Radack, Mark Willard, and Mark Gebauer of Eckert Seamins Cherin & Mellot. The case has been assigned to Yvette Kane.



Friday, February 14, 2014

Comment Period Now Closed on Proposed Rules for Hague Agreement Implementation

On November 29th, 2013, the USPTO published its proposed rules for implementing the Hague Agreement, inviting public comment on their proposals. On February 4th, the period for submitting comments ended. The USPTO will now consider those comments in finalizing its rules.

As discussed in an earlier post, the Hague Agreement provides a streamlined framework for applicants from member nations to obtain international coverage for design patents.

Included among the public comments received by the USPTO is a submission from the Intellectual Property Owners Association, a trade association for owners of patents, copyrights, trademarks, and trade secrets.

In their comments, the IPO noted two sources of concern.

First, the proposed rules do not provide for filing a continued prosecution application (CPA) in an international design application. CPAs are an inexpensive and quick method for resolving small issues late in prosecution, without having to file a continuation application. The IPO suggests altering the rules to provide for CPAs or a functional equivalent.

Second, the IPO expressed concern that the rules do not address a fee issue that could potentially result in a delayed filing date. Under the proposed rules, fees will ultimately be paid to WIPO, the World Intellectual Property Organization, an organization located in Geneva, Switzerland that will administer the international system. The IPO notes that fluctuations in the exchange rate could result in inadvertently minor deficiencies in the fee amounts. The IPO suggests that the USPTO should provide assurances that such a deficiency would not result in a delayed filing date, or otherwise provide against the possibility of deficiencies due to fluctuating exchange rates.

Final rules are expected from the USPTO in the coming months.