Showing posts with label damages. Show all posts
Showing posts with label damages. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 30, 2017

District Court Mulls Design Patent Damages – Apple v. Samsung on Remand

Editor's Note:  The following guest post was authored by Thomas P. McNulty, Counsel at Lando & Anastasi LLP.  

In last year’s Samsung v. Apple decision, the Supreme Court held that the “article of manufacture” for which total profits are awarded upon a finding of design patent infringement may be either “a product sold to a consumer [or] a component of that product.”  The Supreme Court declined to establish the test for identifying the article of manufacture, instead remanding for consideration by the court below.

Given that the Supreme Court substantially changed the interpretation of damages under 35 U.S.C. § 289, it would seem clear that a new damages trial would be required. Nothing in litigation, however, is so simple. Instead, upon remand, the district court considered the parties positions on whether a new trial is warranted.  In the meantime, we will examine the procedural questions addressed by the district court in connection with its order requesting further briefing.

Tuesday, December 6, 2016

Supreme Court Sides with Samsung on Design Patent Damages

On December 6, 2016, the Supreme Court issued a unanimous opinion authored by Justice Sotomayor in the Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. v. Apple, Inc. case concerning apportionment of design patent damages under 35 U.S.C. § 289. Specifically, § 289 makes it unlawful to produce or sell an “article of manufacture” bearing a patented design and makes infringers liable to the patent holder “to the extent of [their] total profit.” The Supreme Court’s ruling rejects Apple’s argument and holds that the meaning of the phrase “article of manufacture” can refer to a single component within a multicomponent product sold to consumers. In support of its reasoning, the Court cites a similarly broad interpretation of the phrase as previously applied to 35 U.S.C. § 171. The § 171 statute defines subject-matter eligibility for design patents.

Tuesday, October 4, 2016

Apple v. Samsung - Preview of Upcoming Oral Arguments before the Supreme Court of the United States


After a brief hiatus, nothing helps to kickstart the Ordinary Observer blog like another episode in the Apple v. Samsung saga. This installment, of course, takes place at the Supreme Court with next week’s oral arguments on the all-important apportionment issue. For those who are casually following the case or just need a refresher, we summarize the party positions and key amicus briefs after the jump. We’ll also be reporting from the Court next week so stay tuned for a first-hand account of the arguments and predictions from the courthouse steps next Tuesday.

Friday, December 4, 2015

A Cautionary Tale: How Not Marking a Product Can Cost a Design Patent Owner

A recent grant of summary judgment to defendants proved just how important it is to clearly mark products and communicate design patent rights to the public. On November 4, Judge Paul Barbadoro of the District of New Hampshire granted the defendants’ motion for summary judgment as to the plaintiffs' claims of patent infringement in a two-year case regarding funeral equipment. See Gallagher et al. v. Funeral Source One Supply and Equipment Co., Inc., et al., 14-cv-115-PB (D.N.H 2015). The case stands as a reminder of what can happen when design patent owners fail to properly mark their products with the patent number. 

Friday, November 6, 2015

Design Patent Remedies - Nordock v. Systems, Inc. (Fed. Cir. 2015)

Recently, the Federal Circuit addressed the dichotomy between standard patent damages under  35 U.S.C. 284 and design patent specific remedies under 35 U.S.C. 289. In Nordock v. Systems Inc., No. 14-1762 (Fed. Cir. Sept. 29, 2015), the Federal Circuit articulated, "[i]n the case of design patent infringement, a patentee can recover damages under 284 or under 35 U.S.C. 289 . . . ", but not both. (Emphasis added). While prior to Nordock this was already understood to be the correct law, we now have a case that confirms that a design patent holder may elect to receive an award under section 284, or section 289, whichever is larger. For the particulars of Nordock v. Systems follow the jump.

D579,754

Wednesday, October 30, 2013

Damages Experts Test the Court in Apple and Samsung Patent Dispute

Some of the interest in the long running patent dispute between Apple and Samsung has waned in the wake of the August, 2012 jury verdict awarding Apple more than one billion dollars in damages for Samsung’s infringement of a combination of utility patents, design patents and a assorted registered and unregistered trade dress. The case is ongoing, however, and new developments have occurred in the past few weeks.