Showing posts with label BPLA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label BPLA. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 30, 2013

The Design Patent/Copyright Conundrum ~ Roundtable Lunch Seminar


On Thursday January 24th, we attended The Design Patent/Copyright Conundrum Roundtable Seminar organized by the Copyright Committee of Boston Patent Law Association (BPLA), where Keith Toms and Erik Paul Belt from McCarter & English presented on the differences in protection afforded by design patents, trade dress, and copyrights.  Various topics were discussed including overlap in protections (see chart below) and recent cases such as Richardson v. Stanley Works and Apple v. Samsung.

 The seminar was well attended by the area’s intellectual properly practitioners, leaving no room at the table.  Presenters inspired lively discussions among the participants on such topics as the scope of protection of Apple design patents and role of design patents in emerging issues such as 3D printing technologies.  Presenters were gracious enough to allow us to share some of the presentation slides with you. Of particular interest is this comparison chart organizing the scope of protection afforded by design patents, copyright and trade dress.


As one might expect, much of the discussion centered around Apple v. Samsung and the forthcoming appeal.  In particular, there was a great deal of discussion regarding Apple’s Design Patent No. 604,305 for a “Graphical User Interface for a Display Screen or Portion Thereof.”   Based on the discussion, it was clear that the design patent community is eagerly anticipating the Federal Circuit’s discussion with regard to this particular patent.  



We thoroughly enjoyed the presentation and the discussion and would like to thank the presenters and organizers for putting together such a relevant and engaging seminar. 

Monday, January 14, 2013

Design Patent Links – January 14, 2013


Christopher Carani of McAndrews, Held & Malloy wrote an excellent analysis of Apple’s smartphone litigation with Samsung and several other design patent cases in an effort to discern some overall guidelines for assessing design patent infringement under the ordinary observer test.  Mr. Carani’s article was re-posted by permission on Patently-O.

Speaking of Apple v. Samsung, the German version of their ongoing design patent war will be delayed after some fancy footwork by Samsung in the EU Trademark Office in Alicante, Spain, as reported by Bloomberg.

Stephen L. Peterson of Finnegan, Henderson, recently penned an article on Lexology.com discussing several myths about design patent, including the misguided theory that “Design patents can’t protect fashion.”

IP360 recently posted an article discussing the “Benefits of US Implementation of the Hague Agreement” and the effect on international design patent prosecution. (account required).   Several other commentators recently discussed the ratification of the Hague Agreement as well, including JDSupra , Tom’s Hardware, and Bloomberg Businessweek.

Foss Patents is reporting on an anonymous ex parte reexamination of Apple’s design patent covering a page turning animation.  Apple’s page turning design patents were subject to widespread criticism when they first issued in light of traditional books and the breadth of the patents.  We will monitor this reexamination and update as warranted.

For those who live in the Boston area, the Boston Patent Law Association will be hosting a roundtable lunch seminar on “The Design Patent/Copyright Conundrum” on January 24, 2013 at Bingham McCutchen.  The roundtable will include discussion of the nature and scope of protection afforded by design patents and copyrights, the overlap in protection between the two, standards for infringement, and remedies available for infringement of design patents and copyrights.